The Cookie Option

Have a sweet tooth, but too far for cake pick-up?

We bake and ship cookies too, just for you.

Cardamom Espresso Chocolate Chunk - The signature cake is now a cookie

Double Chocolate Peanut Butter – Hello!!

Extrorda-Cherry Chocolate Chunk Cookies - Turning the Tollhouse classic on it’s head

Oat and Tahini – With hazelnuts and hints of orange - Borrowing from Chef Ottolenghi

The Cookie – Salted Chocolate Chunk Shortbread - A NY Times favorite

Cakes By Request can prepare a batch just the way you want them!

Step 1 – pick one base dough

Step 2 – pick 1 or 2 or even 3 add-ins

Step 3 – enjoy!

Doughs

• Toll-house base dough

• Oatmeal base dough

• Chocolate base dough

Add-ins

• Dark Chocolate chunks

• Milk Chocolate chunks

• M&M’s

• Slivered Almonds

• Pecans

• Walnuts

• Raisins

$85 for a batch (approx. 2lbs of cookies).

Love the smell of cookies baking? Cookie dough can portioned out and frozen for you to bake at home. Perfect for locals. Just toss in a preheated oven when you want ‘em. Easy breezy!